Missing your ex during the holidays? Here's the pattern
The song in the grocery store, the ornament you bought together, the quiet on the 24th. Missing an ex this time of year is so predictable that research can almost map it. That's good news: it means the feeling is about the season as much as the person, and it passes.

Missing your ex during the holidays is one of the most predictable patterns in breakup research, and it isn’t a sign that you made a mistake. Holidays are full of nostalgia triggers (songs, rituals, places), and nostalgia shows up most when people feel low or lonely. Add the extra fear of being single that this season brings, and longing for an ex goes up on cue. Knowing that it’s the pattern, not a prophecy, is most of what you need to get through it with your dignity intact.
Why does the holiday season bring an ex back to mind?
Because the season is basically a nostalgia machine. In a set of seven studies, Tim Wildschut, Constantine Sedikides and colleagues found that nostalgic memories usually involve close others and big shared moments, and that nostalgia is set off by negative moods and specifically by loneliness.1 In plain terms: the ornament from your first apartment together, plus a quiet evening, is close to a perfect recipe.
The same studies found that nostalgia mostly feels good. It strengthens the sense of connection and lifts mood.1 That’s why the memory feels warm, not just sad, and why it can be confused with a reason to reach out. It’s doing a different job: reminding you that you can love someone. It isn’t telling you to love that same person again.
Why does it feel stronger when you’re alone?
Researchers Stephanie Spielmann, Geoff MacDonald and Samantha Joel tracked people for a month after a breakup. On days when their fear of being single was stronger, they longed for their ex more and made more attempts to get back together. Fear of being single also rose after a breakup no matter who ended things. And the timing suggested that the fear drove the longing, not the other way around.2
Translated into what you can see: the 10 p.m. surge of missing them on December 23rd often has more to do with how alone that night feels than with anything about them. It’s a mood with a face attached.
A related study followed people who were already in new relationships. When those relationships got worse, people’s longing for their exes went up, as if the ex was filling a need the present wasn’t.3 So if you’re with someone now and an ex has been on your mind, the question worth asking is less “do I still love them?” and more “what am I missing this month?”
Does checking their stories help or hurt?
It mostly keeps the loop going. In a survey of 431 people, distress after a breakup predicted monitoring the ex on social media, especially for people who hadn’t chosen the breakup.4 The holidays are prime time for this: the family photos, the new partner at their parents’ table.
You don’t need to feel embarrassed for wanting to look. You do want to make it harder. Mute for the month, log out of the app on your phone, or ask a friend to hold your password till the 26th. Skipping the checks for a few weeks usually makes the urge easier to ride out.
What helps the feeling pass?
Two findings, both kinder than “just get over it.”
Reflecting helps. In a study of 210 recently separated young adults, people who were asked to think and talk about their breakup several times over nine weeks recovered faster. Their sense of who they were became clearer, and that clarity explained why intrusive thoughts and loneliness dropped.5 A few honest pages in a journal this month is a version of the same thing.
Some breakups make room for you. In a study of 155 undergraduates who’d had a recent breakup, people who left relationships that hadn’t helped them grow reported growth afterward, tied to rediscovering parts of themselves they’d set aside.6 Use the holidays to do one of those things again: the instrument, the friend group, the city you liked before them.
A plan for the predictable nights
- Name your triggers in advance. The song, the drive, the family event. When one hits, you’ll recognize it as a trigger instead of a sign.
- Schedule the loneliest evening. For most people it’s one of the nights right before Christmas. Put a friend, a movie or a plan there.
- Write the text you won’t send. Notes app, not the thread. Read it again in the morning.
- If they reach out first, answer warmly and briefly (see the scripts). A holiday greeting is not a conversation you have to have.
What doesn’t the research show?
- The nostalgia studies were about nostalgia in general, not exes or holidays.
- The fear-of-being-single studies followed people over a month and a few months. They show a strong pattern, not that every pang is about fear.
- The ex-appeal study used people in current relationships; it may apply differently if you’re single.
- The social-media study was a one-time survey about Facebook, and it shows a link, not cause.
- The reflection and growth studies used young adults and undergraduates, so older readers should treat them as a guide, not a guarantee.
Try it
The season or the person? Sort what's pulling you back
Steal this text
Say it in your own words, or start from these
To a friend, instead of the ex
Okay, I'm having a 'miss my ex' moment because of a song in a store. Talk me down with a story about your week?
In your notes app, the text you won't send
I miss the holidays we had. I don't miss what happened after. Both are true. Not sending this.
If the ex texts you 'merry christmas'
Merry Christmas, I hope it's a good one.
Know someone who's missing an ex this season?
Send them this instead of advice. Add a line if you want; then it goes straight to them.
Nothing you type here is saved or sent anywhere unless you send it yourself.
People who talk about this
- Credentialed source
Alexandra H. Solomon
Relational self awareness, dating and building lasting relationships, drawn from her couples work and her Northwestern course.
- Credentialed source
Bella DePaulo
Research and writing on single life, including people who choose to stay single and live full lives on their own terms.
- Credentialed source
Eli J. Finkel
Research on how modern marriage and long term relationships work, and what partners expect from each other.
- Credentialed source
- Trending voice
Julie Menanno
How couples get stuck in conflict cycles and how to feel secure with a partner.
Sources
- Nostalgia: Content, triggers, functions
- Longing for Ex-Partners out of Fear of Being Single
- Ex Appeal: Current Relationship Quality and Emotional Attachment to Ex-Partners
- Romantic Partner Monitoring After Breakups: Attachment, Dependence, Distress, and Post-Dissolution Online Surveillance via Social Networking Sites
- Participating in Research on Romantic Breakups Promotes Emotional Recovery via Changes in Self-Concept Clarity
- Addition through subtraction: Growth following the dissolution of a low quality relationship