Dating Patterns

Patterns

Sunk cost in relationships: why people stay too long

You've already put in the years, the money, the effort. Walking away can feel like wasting all of it. Psychologists have a name for that feeling, and a set of experiments that show when it actually sways the decision to stay.

At a kitchen table late in the evening, a man in his early 30s with a close-cropped beard sits with both hands around a mug, looking at an empty second chair rather than at the dark window behind him.
Illustration. AI-generated image.

You’ve already put years into this. Maybe a lease, a dog, a group of friends who know you as a pair. Walking away can feel like throwing that away, which is why the decision gets so sticky. Psychologists call that the sunk cost effect: letting resources you cannot get back decide what you do next.4

The feeling is ordinary. Whether it should settle the question is another matter, and that is what the relationship studies tried to test.

Does a past investment really make people stay?

In one set of experiments, people were asked to imagine an unhappy relationship and decide whether to stay or leave. When the scenario included money already spent, or effort already poured in, more people chose to stay. A past investment of time, on its own, did not have that effect in the first experiment. A second experiment measured the decision differently, asking how much more time people were willing to put in, and there a sunk-time effect showed up: the longer the relationship had already lasted, the more future time people said they would give it.1

These were hypothetical scenarios, not diaries of real breakups, and they cannot tell you what you should do. They do show that the “we’ve already put so much in” instinct is easy to trigger, especially around money and effort.

Are all investments the same?

Not in the research that looked more closely. A 2008 paper split investments by timing, past versus planned, and by type, tangible versus intangible. Across five samples, the investments that most consistently predicted commitment, whether the relationship lasted, and how hard a breakup later felt were the intangible ones, and the ones still planned for the future.2

That complicates the simple sunk-cost story. A shared apartment is a past, tangible cost. A plan to move cities together, or years of actually telling each other the truth, is a different kind of stake. The first is already spent. The second is a claim about what you still want.

What else keeps people in?

A much older model of commitment, tested with college students in real relationships, found three ingredients, not one. People were more committed when they were more satisfied, when they saw poorer alternatives, and when they had invested more. Commitment, in turn, predicted whether the relationship continued.3

So “I’ve already put so much in” can be one reason you stay. It can also sit beside “I don’t see anything better” or “this is still mostly good.” Those are worth pulling apart, because they point to different next steps.

How do you use this without turning it into a scorecard?

A sunk cost, by definition, cannot be recovered whether you stay or go.4 The useful question is forward-looking: given what you know now, do you want the next year of this? If the honest answer depends mostly on not wasting the last five years, that is the effect the experiments were studying.

If the honest answer is that you still have plans, or that the day-to-day is still good enough, that is closer to the investments that predicted staying in the 2008 samples.2

The same fork shows up after a betrayal, and should I stay after cheating is about that narrower case. If the relationship simply feels flat, why do I get bored in relationships is a better fit than a sunk-cost frame.

Quick recap

  • Sunk costs are unrecoverable, whether you stay or leave.4
  • Money and effort already spent made people more likely to stay in a hypothetical unhappy relationship.1
  • Planned and intangible investments predicted commitment more consistently than past tangible costs.2
  • Satisfaction, alternatives, and investment all fed commitment in the original investment model.3

Try it

What's doing most of the work in the decision to stay?

We've already put so much in

That's the sunk cost talking

In the unhappy-relationship experiments, a past outlay of money or effort made people more likely to stay. The years already spent are real. They are also gone either way.

Your next step: Write down what would have to be true from here, ignoring what you've already spent.

I still have plans with this person

Planned investments are a different signal

In five samples, planned future investments and intangible ones, like time and disclosure, predicted commitment more reliably than past tangible costs. Wanting a future is not the same as protecting a past bill.

Your next step: List the plans you still want, and whether they still want them too.

I don't love it, but I don't see another option

Alternatives sit in the model too

The investment model found commitment rose not only with satisfaction and past investment, but also when people saw poorer alternatives. Feeling stuck can be about the options, not just the history.

Your next step: Name one alternative you have actually considered, even a modest one, and what it would take.

I'm trying to tell whether this is a rough patch

Look at what's changing, not just what's been spent

A sunk cost is, by definition, unrecoverable. A rough patch is a bet that something ahead will be different. Those are different questions.

Your next step: Pick one problem and ask what, concretely, is different about it now than a year ago.

People who talk about this

Labeled by where their authority comes from. Not a ranking, not an endorsement.

  • Credentialed source

Alexandra H. Solomon

Relational self awareness, dating and building lasting relationships, drawn from her couples work and her Northwestern course.

Licensed clinical psychologist; adjunct professor, School of Education and Social Policy, Northwestern University · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Bella DePaulo

Research and writing on single life, including people who choose to stay single and live full lives on their own terms.

Social psychologist (PhD, Harvard); academic affiliate, Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, UC Santa Barbara · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Eli J. Finkel

Research on how modern marriage and long term relationships work, and what partners expect from each other.

Professor of Psychology and of Management and Organizations, Northwestern University; director of the Relationships and Motivation Lab · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source
  • Trending voice

Julie Menanno

How couples get stuck in conflict cycles and how to feel secure with a partner.

Licensed marriage and family therapist (MA, LMFT, LCPC); author of Secure Love · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

All 16 people we point to →

Sources

  1. Is there a Sunk Cost Effect in Committed Relationships?Current Psychology (Rego, Arantes and Magalhaes), 2018Used for: Experiment 1 (902 participants): in a hypothetical unhappy relationship, people were more likely to stay when money or effort had already been invested; a past time investment alone did not have that effect. Experiment 2 (275 participants): people were willing to invest more future time in a relationship that had already lasted longer, a sunk-time effect.
  2. Sunken Costs and Desired Plans: Examining Different Types of Investments in Close RelationshipsPersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin (Goodfriend and Agnew), 2008Used for: Across five samples, investments were split by timing (past vs planned) and materiality (tangible vs intangible). Intangible investments and planned future investments were especially robust predictors of commitment, stability, and how hard a breakup later hit.
  3. Commitment and satisfaction in romantic associations: A test of the investment modelJournal of Experimental Social Psychology (Caryl E. Rusbult), 1980Used for: In two studies of college students in ongoing relationships, commitment was greater when satisfaction was higher, when the quality of alternatives was poorer, and when more had been invested in the relationship, and commitment in turn predicted whether the relationship persisted.
  4. The psychology of sunk costOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes (Arkes and Blumer), 1985Used for: Classic experiments defined the sunk cost effect: people continue a course of action because of resources already spent, even when those costs cannot be recovered and a different choice would be better going forward.
Up nextOn again, off again: what research says about the cycle